Categories
News

Blasting the Zombie Out of Water-Saving Technology

A team of scientists, including experts from the University of Adelaide, suggest that reliance on modern irrigation technologies as a water-use efficiency strategy is a ‘zombie idea’ – one that persists no matter how much evidence is thrown against it.

In a paper in Environmental Research Letters, the international research team reviewed more than 200 supporting research articles and found technology adoption as a water-saving method for improving irrigation efficiency is ineffective, and can actually worsen water scarcity.

“This is because, while water may be saved per hectare on a farm, it typically encourages taking those water savings and putting them back into production, thus there are no ‘savings’ from the total water use equation,” said co-author Adam Loch, Associate Professor at the University of Adelaide’s Centre for Global Food and Resources.

“It’s an idea that sounds logical, but a hard look at the data shows just the opposite. Water-use efficiency investments can actually increase local water consumption and contribute to aquifer depletion.

“We’ve known this for decades, but despite such knowledge, this idea persists and flourishes.”

The paper identifies several reasons why, in the face of contrary evidence, the idea that modern application technology (e.g. drip irrigation) saves water consumption persists, including beliefs and prior decisions that are hard to reverse.

“We continually fail to understand the limitations of technology, which at best may only achieve a 10-20 per cent saving under ideal conditions, and where saved water is often placed into new production.” — Associate Professor Adam Loch, the University of Adelaide’s Centre for Global Food and Resources.

The researchers suggest, some of the key players who continually support the ‘zombie idea’ include those who sell water-use efficiency equipment; politicians who prefer simple popularist solutions; and donor organizations who want easy investable options, rather than dealing with hard and unpopular choices.

“It may be easy for some of these groups to champion water-use efficiency, but they don’t have to carry the can when it fails to deliver real savings long-term,” said Associate Professor Loch.

“We continually fail to understand the limitations of technology, which at best may only achieve a 10-20 percent saving under ideal conditions, and where saved water is often placed into new production,” said Dr David Adamson, co-author from the University of Adelaide’s Centre for Global Food and Resources.

“Most farmers don’t choose to invest in these technologies without financial assistance like subsidies because they know the limits of these systems and their capacity to permit further benefits.”

This result has been consistently observed around the globe, and it’s a growing concern in arid regions that have tapped their non-renewable fossil aquifer supplies (deep underground reserves of water) to maintain farm production.

“It’s an unfortunate and ‘inconvenient truth’ that modernization, touted as a boom for greater water efficiency, isn’t saving water as far as our aquifers, or indeed our rivers are concerned,” said Dr. Adamson.

So, why do some governments continue to promote drip-irrigation? The authors suggest several reasons, among them corporate incentives to sell equipment and the fact that farmers genuinely appreciate the subsidies (as much as 90 per cent in some places) provided by governments.

“Subsidies may help them switch to higher-value perennial crops (like almonds), and increase local production without understanding the risk of future water scarcity due to droughts and climate change,” said Dr. Adamson.

“That’s great for these farmers in the short-term. But it exposes them to greater vulnerability and debt when droughts occur and droughts are expected to become more frequent in the future.”

Associate Professor Loch said while the recent evidence that increased irrigation efficiency tends to increase water consumption continues to be ignored, the reliability of future water supply is declining.

“We need to spread the word that modernization and other subsidized investments in irrigation, aren’t the silver bullet to conserving water and sustaining our agricultural production systems into the future.”

In their research, the team outline a plan for future water-saving interventions. The plan includes properly accounting for water use before an intervention as well as after it to measure savings accurately, engaging with engineers to better appreciate modernization limits, and informing downstream users of how they will be affected to ensure changes are reasonable and positive.

“Finally, being ready to implement these changes during the next shock (e.g. drought), when stakeholders will be less resistant to change, may finally put this zombie idea to rest,” Associate Professor Loch said.

Reference: “Agricultural water saving through technologies: a zombie idea” by C. Dionisio Pérez-Blanco, Adam Loch, Frank Ward, Chris Perry and David Adamson, Accepted, Environmental Research Letters.
DOI: 10.1088/1748-9326/ac2fe0

https://ideone.com/zzxBR0

https://www.deviantart.com/jamesjasaa/journal/AIBA-World-Championships-2021-Live-Stream-Online-896367746

https://www.deviantart.com/jamesjasaa/journal/Livestream-Watch-or-Broadcast-Live-Events-896367817

https://tautaruna.nra.lv/forums/tema/46477-live-stream-all-sports-online-full-free-watching/

https://vocus.cc/article/617c5e2cfd897800011f8f6e

https://vocus.cc/article/617c5be2fd897800011f8865

https://paiza.io/projects/xF3DSUjyd9_ixIGb9JWkRA?language=php

https://www.onfeetnation.com/photo/albums/stem-rust

https://caribbeanfever.com/photo/albums/abstract-astrophysics-alien-signal-concept

https://pastebin.com/ZwRULp85

https://pastelink.net/v4v8jdic

https://pastebin.fun/k9kr34frft

https://onecompiler.com/java/3xfvg4tub

http://cpp.sh/34iqs

https://www.peeranswer.com/question/617c569e122c3c2d09097816

http://paste.hexsolutions.net/5519194

https://pastebin.freeswitch.org/view/f6302600

https://www.88posts.com/post/790405/bapco-6-hours-of-bahrain-2021-live-styreaming-fg91-motorsport-live4k

http://paste.jp/9a67a9e7/

https://ctxt.io/2/AABgcbY9EQ

https://www.pastery.net/cshyrr/

https://paste.ee/p/vQ4TB

https://www.bankier.pl/forum/temat_https-ctxt-io-2-aabgcby9eq,50628951.html

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/hd-world-wheelchair-curling-championship-2021-live-at-stream-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live~streams-world-wheelchair-curling-championship-2021-livestream-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-tv-canadian-olympic-curling-pre-trials-2021-live-streams-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/watch-free-canadian-olympic-curling-pre-trials-2021-live-at-stream-free-online

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-slash-tv-americas-challenge-2021-live-stream-curling-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/curlingzone-americas-challenge-2021-live-at-stream-free-hd-4k

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-tv-americas-zone-challenge-2021-live-at-streams-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/curling-streams-americas-zone-challenge-2021-live-on-30-october-dot

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-tv-grand-prix-bern-inter-curling-challenge-2021-live-at-streams-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/watch-grand-prix-bern-inter-curling-challenge-2021-live-online-free-curling

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-tv-boundary-ford-curling-classic-2021-live-at-streams-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/watch-free-boundary-ford-curling-classic-2021-live-streaming-currling

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-tv-wct-heracles-mixed-doubles-slovakia-cup-2021-live-at-stream-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/%60wct-heracles-mixed-doubles-slovakia-cup%60-2021-live~stream-free-curling

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-atlantic-superstore-monctonian-challenge-2021-live-at-livestream

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-tv-atlantic-superstore-monctonian-challenge-2021-live-at-stream-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-tv-challenge-nord-ouest-air-creebec-2021-live-at-streams-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/curlingzone-challenge-nord-ouest-air-creebec-2021-livestreams-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-tv-sct-mixed-doubles-prince-albert-2021-live-at-streams-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/watch-free-sct-mixed-doubles-prince-albert-live-online-curling

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/%60palmerston-mixed-doubles-spiel%60-2021-live-at-streams-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/curlingzone-palmerston-mixed-doubles-spiel-2021-live-at-streaming-online-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/free-2021-autumn-talents-cup-ukraine-live-livestream

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/2021-22-figure-skating-autumn-talents-cup-ukraine-%7C-live

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestream-denis-ten-memorial-challenge-2021-livestream

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-streaming-2021-denis-ten-memorial-challenge-live-online-2021

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestream-at-tirnavia-ice-cup-2021

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestream-tirnavia-ice-cup-figure-skating-2021-%3Clive

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-tv-skate-canada-international-2021-figure-skating-live-stream-tv-schedule-how-to-watch

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/watch-the-isu-grand-prix-of-figure-skating-skate-canada-live-at-streaming-online-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/isu-skate-canada-figure-skating-2021-live-stream-tv-schedule-how-to-watch

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/%3C%3Clive%3E%3E-skate-canada-international-2021-livestream

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/isu-grand-prix-of-figure-skating-2021-online

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestreams-2021-isu-grand-prix-of-figure-skating-skate-canada

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/watch-free-bwf-french-open-badminton-live-stream-2021-online

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-tv-french-open-badminton-2021-live~streaming-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestream-at-bucharest-marathon-2021-live-race-route-online-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live%60stream-raiffeisen-bank-bucharest-marathon-2021-liveonline-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-tv-khsaa-state-cross-country-championships-2021-live-at-streaming-online-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-number-khsaa-state-cross-country-championships-2021-liveonline-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/2021-world-triathlon-cup-tongyeong-live-at-streams-star-30-31-oct-2021-star-tongyeong-korea-south

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestream-star-star-number-2021-world-triathlon-cup-tongyeong-at-live-2021

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live~streams-number-2021-world-triathlon-aquathlon-championships-el-anillo-live-extremadura

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-tv-2021-world-triathlon-aquathlon-championships-el-anillo-extremadura-live-at-streams-star-30-oct-2021-star-el-anillo-extremadura-spain

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-tv-2021-chsaa-xc-championships-livestream-at-2021

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-free-chsaa-cross-country-championship-finals-2021-live-at-stream-free-tv

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/flotrack-2021-wvssac-xc-championships-live-at-stream-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-tv-2021-wvssac-xc-championships-free-live-streams-livestream

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live~tv-beast-championship-8-live-stream-fight-card-start-time-and-tv

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestream-~-number-beast-championship-8-live

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-tv-watch-british-fast5-netball-all-stars-championships-2021-live-stream-on-30-october-2021

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-at-british-fast5-netball-all-stars-championship-live-at-streams-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestream-2021-coa-louisville-challenge-at-live-2021

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-tv-2021-coa-louisville-challenge-livestream-live

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-stream-nordic-junior-championships-gymnastics-2021-live-stream

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/fig-at-nordic-junior-championships-gymnastics-2021-live-at-stream-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-tv-fig-gymnastics-rhythmic-world-championships-live-stream-tv-channel-start-time

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestreaming-2021-rhythmic-gymnastics-world-championships-kitakyushu-japan-live-stream

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/dubai-muscle-classic-2021-livestream

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livenow-dubai-muscle-classic-2021-livestream%3E-number-live

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-ifbb-diamond-cup-serbia-2021-live-livestream

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livenow-%3E%3E-2021-ifbb-diamond-cup-serbia-livestream

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live%60stream-ifbb-pepa-grand-prix-2021-live-online-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestream-ifbb-pepa-grand-prix-2021-livestream

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-ifbb-fit-model-world-championships-riga-2021-livestream

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-tv-2021-ifbb-fit-model-world-championships-livestream-live

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-streams-2021-jim-morris-classic-liveonline-free-2021

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/ifbb-2021-jim-morris-classic-livestream-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-streams-wales-vs-new-zealand-all-blacks-live-stream-and-how-to-watch-2021-autumn-internationals-for-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/%60wales-vs-new-zealand%60-free-live-stream-on-30-october-saturday

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/reddit-wales-vs-all-blacks-rugby-live-at-streaming-online-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/%60wales-vs-all-blacks%60-free-live-streaming-new-zealand-walsh-rugby-online-stream-tv-nz-abs-vs-wru-rugby-game-30-oct-2021

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/rugby-slash-streams-wales-vs-new-zealand-live-online-free-on-30th-october

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-wales-vs-all-blacks-rugby-game-live-streaming-reddit-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/%60scotland-vs-tonga%60-live-at-streaming-reddit-free-preview-live-match-%7C-30-oct-2021

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestreams-scotland-vs-tonga-rugby-live-at-stream-reddit-free-on-30-oct-2021

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-ultimate-strongman-world-championship-iii-2021-live-stream-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/%60ultimate-strongman-world-championship-iii-2021%60-live-at-streams-free-online-hd-4k

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-victoria-derby-day-2021-free-live-stream-field-odds-and-tv-coverage-info

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/horse-victoria-derby-day-2021-live-at-stream-full-horse-racing-online-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-tv-the-golden-eagle-2021-live-at-stream-horses-field-race-time-results

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestream-2021-golden-eagle-horse-race-live-online-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-stream-emma-eternal-mma-62-livestream

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-eternal-62-live-stream-on-saturday-30-october-2021-how-to-watch-eternal-mma-live

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestream-~-emma-eternal-mma-62-%7C-live2021

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/tickets-eternal-mma-62-live-at-stream-free-mt-claremont-sat-30-oct

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestream-belgrade-world-championships-wrestling-2021-live-stream-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/uww-belgrade-world-championships-wrestling-2021-live

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-slash-streams-mediterranean-karate-championships-2021-live

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/set-at-dtm-at-live-stream-mediterranean-championships-2021

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-stream-2021-uww-senior-world-grappling-championships-on-flograppling

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestream-senior-world-grappling-championships-2021-live-online-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestream-2021-ultimate-club-nationals-liveonline-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/streams-ultimate-club-nationals-2021-live-at-stream-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/flowrestling-halloween-monster-bash-duals-2021-live-stream-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestream-halloween-monster-bash-duals-2021-live-on-flowrestling

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/%60%60monster-bash-women%60s-tournament%60-2021-live-stream-on-flowrestling-2021

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-monster-bash-women%60s-tournament-flowrestling-2021-live-on-29-31-october-dot

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-brian-keck-memorial-nationals-2021-live-oct-29-31-on-flowrestling

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/stream-brian-keck-memorial-preseason-nationals-2021-live-online-free-on-29-31-octobert

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/bapco-6-hours-of-bahrain-2021-%7C-live-styreaming-%7C-fg91-motorsport

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestream-star-star-wec-bahrain-6-hours-live-online-race-29-30-october

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestream-2021-aiba-youth-world-boxing-championship-live-online-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestream-2021-aiba-youth-world-boxing-championship-liveonline-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/live-2021-fia-motorsport-games-live-at-streams-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/hd-fia-motorsport-games-2021-livestream-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestream-2021-world-rugby-sevens-singapore-live-stream-free-on-28-31-october-dot

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/watch-free-hsbc-singapore-rugby-sevens-2021-live%60stream

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/the-2021-world-series-of-darts-finals-live-streams-reddit

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/%60world-series-of-darts-finals%60-2021-live-op-tv-en-online-on-28-31-october

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/floracing-ama-cal-classic-2021-live-at-streaming-online-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestream-ama-cal-classic-2021-live-floracing2021

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/floracing-endurocross-at-national-western-center-2021-live-on-28-31-october-dot

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestream-star-endurocross-at-national-western-center-2021-live-online-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/stream-2021-national-100-at-east-alabama-motor-speedway-live-starting-at-oct-29-on-floracing

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/floracing-2021-national-100-at-east-alabama-live-oct-29-31

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/watch-jambalaya-100-at-pike-county-live-at-streams-free-floracing

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/floracing-jambalaya-100-at-pike-county-2021-live-streaming-online-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/watch-2021-usac-wsm-at-keller-auto-speedway-live-on-floracing

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/2021-anthony-simone-classic-at-keller-auto-speedway-live-at-stream-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/livestreams-mid-atlantic-championships-at-georgetown-floracing-live

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/%60mid-atlantic-championship-weekend%60-2021-live-at-stream-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/floracing-2021-narc-king-of-the-west-live-number-at-stream-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/narc-king-of-the-west-2021-live-on-floracing

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/floracing-2021-season-opener-at-riverside-speedway-live-at-streams-free

https://americanprep.instructure.com/courses/13616/pages/season-opener-2021-at-riverside-speedway-live-on-floracing-free

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *